The Windup Girl – Paolo Bacigalupi

Book: The Windup Girl
Author: Paolo Bacigalupi
Publisher: Nightshade Books
Hardcover, 359 pages
My Rating:
              3h stars

The Windup Girl is a dystopian biopunk novel that occurs in the city of Bangkok. Vehicles run on fossil fuels are scarce and most food and many animals have been genetically altered. Anderson Lake is a farang businessman for a calorie company and searches the streets of Bangkok for food that is resistant to disease. His assistant, Hock Seng, is a Yellow Card that helps Anderson run the factory. The two work hard to keep the factory ahead of the pace of diseases like cibiscosis and blister rust that ruins foodstuffs and causes famine and death. When Anderson meets a windup girl named Emiko his life changes. Windups are viewed as less than human in Thailand, and Emiko is discarded by her owner and works at a club where she is abused. Torn between his obligation to serve his company and his desire to take care of Emiko, Anderson inadvertently sets events in motion that have serious implications.

The Windup Girl was given the 2010 Hugo Award for Best Novel at AussieCon in Melbourne about a month ago. This excited me because I have been looking forward to reading The Windup Girl all year long. I have never read anything by Bacigalupi before, but the book has gotten so much attention and the cover of the book was so appealing that when I finally got a copy, I couldn’t wait to crack open the pages and read the book. What I found was a book that had a thoughtful social commentary on the dangers of GMO foods, corporate control of our food system, and raised ethical questions of genetic engineering. For being a fairly short book at 359 pages, the world building was amazing. There were times that Bacigalupi’s description of the heat in Thailand made me feel like I needed to turn my ceiling fan on and there were times when I could feel the humidity of the Bangkok air. The setting was vibrant but also full of turmoil.

The world building was so well done that the plot didn’t really begin to take shape until midway through the book. I knew the basics of the plot with Anderson searching for the fruit the Thais called gnaw, but the story with Hock Seng, the Environment Ministry white shirts, and Emiko didn’t come together for me until about 150-200 pages in. I have to admit that I struggled some through the first half of the book but once I hit the midway point of the book, I really started enjoying it. The politics of the Environment Ministry, the calorie companies, and the Trade Ministry were complex and felt like it could truly be within the realm of possibility. Food is such a commodity in our society now, that a dystopian vision of GMO foods is something that was very interesting to read about.

The major issue that I had with the book was what Stephanie from Read in a Single Sitting characterizes as a “plate glass" style of writing. For me, the writing was choppy and disconnected from the story. There were times the flow was there but other times the sentences were so short that I felt like I was at a slam poetry performance. Mr. Bacigalupi may have intended this for the novel because society is disconnected in it and there is a constant sense of chaos throughout, but because of this, I admit that I had difficulty getting immersed in the novel. However, I am glad that I persevered and continued reading because the ideas in it are worthy of a read and the world itself is one that is likely to stay in my mind for years to come. While talking to my husband at dinner tonight, I compared this novel to The Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson. That was also a book I struggled through at times, but over time, it was one that really grew on me. I have a feeling The Windup Girl will be much like The Diamond Age in that I think it’s a book that months down the road I will still be digesting. I would recommend this book to people that enjoy dystopian literature that has a striking social commentary, especially with regards to corporations and how they influence the industrial food system, and it challenges readers to contemplate what constitutes our humanity in reference to biological systems.


Note of Interest
Paolo Bacigalupi wrote two short stories related to The Windup Girl in Pump Six and Other Stories. They are called Yellow Card Man and The Calorie Man.


*Notice of Disclosure: I received The Windup Girl for review from Nightshade Books.

**I am a Book Depository and IndieBound afilliate so If you purchase any of the books I have featured through the links I posted or from the banners in my left hand sidebar, I get a small commission from them. I am in no way compensated for the reviews I post of my books.

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Hmm... it sounds like a slow and difficult read, but I'm intrigued!
My recent post Review- No Place Left to Bury the Dead by Nicole Itano
1 reply · active 753 weeks ago
It was slow and kind of difficult but only because it was slow. At 200 pages, it got much more intriguing. It might be one I pick up and read again in a few years to see if I feel different about it. The writing style was what made me feel kind of iffy on it. The ideas in it were VERY well thought out which I liked.
Yeah, that disconnected style of writing + lack of plot was what turned me off for it. i was so frustrated I put it down after about 100 pages and just haven't felt like trying it out again.
1 reply · active 753 weeks ago
Do you think you'll pick it up again at some point or are you just moving on? At about 150 pages, there is definitely an angels singing kind of moment where you are like, "Well that is why I'm reading this!"--because that's when it all really takes shape. Nothing super profound happens, but you understand why you are reading the book between pages 150-200.
I'm impressed that you stuck through it where I would've given up on it. Glad you stuck through to the end and it was semi-worthwhile :D
My recent post Review- Johnny and the Dead by Terry Pratchett
1 reply · active 753 weeks ago
It was worthwhile. I think I will be thinking about this one for months to come. I'm glad I stuck it out.
I tend to dislike that disconnected writing style as well. I like the term you guys came up for it. This sounds really intriguing though. I might have to pick it up.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
It's a short book at 359 pages, but probably one of the more challenging books I've read this year just because of the writing style and the slow moving plot. It's worth picking up though. It's very well thought out and the world Bacigalupi created is pretty interesting. Let me know what you think about it if you do pick it up. It seems to be a love it or hate it kind of book from the reviews I've browsed. I was somewhere in the middle. hehe
I've been considering this one for The Steampunk Challenge... hmmmm I'll have to think about it, not sure the writing style would agree with me.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
It could loosely be classified as steampunk, but I really think it's biopunk rather than steampunk. There are dirigibles in the book but that's about it. It's more about genetic engineering and is definitely not Victorian in any sense. I didn't end up counting it for my steampunk challenge because it just didn't have that steampunk feel. The Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson is called steampunk, but I also don't consider that steampunk. On Wikipedia, it has The Windup Girl listed as biopunk. I agree with that assessment! :)
I can't see myself taking the time to plow through a book like that. As usual, I'm not looking for dystopian worlds to read about, feeling as I do that we often live in one!
My recent post Waving The White Flag
3 replies · active 753 weeks ago
I did actually think it was a worthwhile read, but it is one of those that is more challenging in holding your interest initially. At the end of it, I'm glad I read it even though it wasn't an "I must buy this book for all my friends" read. It's definitely well done and deserves a look, but I would never force anyone to read it if it didn't sound like their cup of tea! :)
I know you wouldn't do that! I think I'm just increasingly dismayed at the amount of dystopian literature written for "young adults" aka kids. Truthfully, it saddness me greatly to think that is what so many young folks are reading so much of. That, combined with the current state of our economy, makes the world a pretty bleak for many, who don't see any reason to continue to live in it. Sigh...
My recent post Waving The White Flag
Hmmm...I am not sure what to say to this because The Windup Girl is definitely not YA. There are some graphic scenes in it and the content and writing is just far too mature for a YA reader.

I think dystopian literature has an important place in society though. Take 1984. Issues in that book are still VERY relevant today and if people didn't write about those things our freedoms would likely not be the same. Some of what he wrote about has actually come true to a certain extent. How many cameras document our movements everyday....so many!

That's what this book accomplishes very well. It's a very good social commentary on our global food systems and how corporations control so much of it. It's just great food for thought. Sure, the world can be a bleak place, but it is also one of hope. I am just not one of those rose colored glasses people and never was. I think dystopian novels can help give young people and adults awareness into issues that they might not know are issues. I don't think that is sad. I think fostering a sense of curiousity and a need to inform ourselves is never a sad thing.

It's when we sit back and accept the world blindly that I would feel life would truly be sad.
This is one I've had my eye on too - I love that cover. It sounds very different from my normal reads so it's definitely on my wish list.

Off topic - I got the Connelly book for your book group. Is that next Sunday? Yikes I better hurry :)
My recent post World Literature
1 reply · active 753 weeks ago
It's the first weekend of November so you have two weeks. :) The book is definitely worth a read. If you'd like to borrow my copy, you are more than welcome to borrow it! I'll bring it to meetup.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Related Posts with Thumbnails
 
Home | Gallery | Tutorials | Freebies | About Us | Contact Us

Copyright © 2009 A Little Bookish |Designed by Templatemo |Converted to blogger by BloggerThemes.Net

Usage Rights

DesignBlog BloggerTheme comes under a Creative Commons License.This template is free of charge to create a personal blog.You can make changes to the templates to suit your needs.But You must keep the footer links Intact.