The Girl Who Played With Fire–Stieg Larsson







Book: The Girl Who Played with Fire
Author: Stieg Larsson
Publisher: Vintage Crime
630 pages (Trade Paperback)
My Rating:
4h stars


Lisbeth Salander has vanished into thin air leaving Mikael Blomkvist wondering what happened in The Girl Who Played with Fire, the second installment of The Millennium Trilogy. Blomkvist has returned to his position at Millennium and is working on a new story involving human trafficking with researchers Dag Svensson and Mia Johanssen. The sex trade is an insidious but thriving business in Sweden and the researchers are about to blow it wide open and name key players in the trade. When Svensson and Johanssen are found murdered, Lisbeth Salander is the prime suspect. Not believing that Lisbeth would commit murder, Blomkvist decides to investigate what happened to his friends and try to clear Lisbeth’s name.

It’s been quite awhile since I picked up the Millennium Trilogy partially because I have sort of been waiting for The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet’s Nest to come out in trade paperback so my set will be complete (yes, I am one of those people that doesn’t like mismatched books). I broke down because several people I knew were reading The Girl Who Played with Fire and I thought it would be fun to talk with them about it. It turned out to be a good book for discussion as we talked about Mikael and Lisbeth as characters as well as some of the supporting characters in the book. There is definitely a need to suspend disbelief in this book just as there was in the first book. One of the main issues people have had with books that I’ve spoken to don’t believe that Lisbeth has Asperger’s Syndrome. I think The Girl Who Played with Fire explores Lisbeth’s behavior much more and makes her less of an enigma than she was in the first book.

The sex trafficking was also a really interesting topic for Larsson to write about since it is such a taboo subject but is so pervasive in society. While it was written in a fictional/thriller style, I think it did bring light to a very serious topic that needs to receive more attention. The book reminded me a little of certain scenes from the movie Taken starring Liam Neeson. I also like how he wove the story together to bring Lisbeth and Mikael onto the investigation together despite Lisbeth being pursued by the authorities. The book also kept with the theme of “men hating women” which makes the books fit together like a puzzle and continually sheds new light on Lisbeth.

I should also note that Lisbeth’s guardian, Bjurman, makes an appearance in The Girl Who Played with Fire. I was hoping that Larsson wouldn’t let that story go by the wayside since it was one of the most memorable storylines in the The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. A mild spoiler alert here: I thought the storyline between Lisbeth and Bjurman came to a really satisfying conclusion in this book.

The only problem I had with the book was the end. One of the final scenes left me scratching my head. For the sake of not spoiling the book for those of you that haven’t read it, I will withhold the specifics, but I will say that I found the end really unbelievable and had to really suspend disbelief to not completely groan at the end. Even with this part, I really enjoyed the book overall and definitely recommend it to those of you that enjoy thrillers.

After I read this book, I watched the Swedish film of the same name. While I didn’t like it quite as much as the first film, it was still really well done. Mikael Nyqvist and Noomi Rapace are amazing actors, and I still can’t quite wrap my finger around the idea of an American film. For one, the books are SO Swedish that I really enjoy listening to the Swedish language in the film even if I can’t understand more than a few words of Swedish! I also think the actors embodied the characters so well in the film that there was no need to make a new version of the film. Yes, it does give Sweden more publicity which I am happy about because for the few days I visited Stockholm some years ago, I fell in love with the city. I would love to go back someday and see more of Sweden. Hopefully a blockbuster American film will show people that Sweden has some excellent writers and amazing culture and beauty. Other than that, I recommend that people see the Swedish version of the film. It’s good to branch out and see how other countries make their films. They usually have such different flavor that I tend to really enjoy them. The major complaint I have about the film in general is that while the book tied Mikael and Lisbeth together quite well, it definitely worked better on paper than it did in the movie. There was a disconnect between Lisbeth and Mikael because they had almost no scenes together in the entire film—the book ties  them together through written word much more effectively than a film ever could. Other than that, it was really well done and I enjoyed it quite a bit. I highly recommend The Girl Who Played with Fire as a great read and a good movie.


1 / 5 books. 20% done!
This is my first book for Zee’s Nordic Challenge


**I am a Book Depository and IndieBound afilliate so If you purchase any of the books I have featured through the links I posted or from the banners in my left hand sidebar, I get a small commission from them. I am in no way compensated for the reviews I post of my books.

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I also enjoyed this book a lot, but I agree that the end is rather unlikely. Didn't you feel you need to read the third book straight away? I was in agony, because I didn't have the 3rd book so I went out and bought it the day after I finished the 2nd book. I couldn't wait!

I like your analysis about the movie(s). I enjoyed them (the Swedish-made ones) but I liked the books much better. I actually read all 3 books twice!

Hope you'll enjoy the 3rd book too.
My recent post Book Review- Spark – How Creativity Works by Julie Burstein DNF
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
I did feel the need to read the third book right away, but I don't own it and don't want to buy it in hardcover. I like the trade paper version of the book so I'm waiting for it. I may get on the library waitlist for the e-book though.

Yeah, the second movie had such a disconnect in it because Lisbeth and Mikael were in different situations. The book was able to tie them together much better than the movie was just because of the power of printed words. I do want to read the third book soon so I can watch the third movie. I <3 Noomi Rapace! She is so amazing!
To me this novel was the worst of the three. The bad guys seemed as if they came right out of a comic book. This is the problem with trilogies, the middle book/movie has no beginning and no end.

Here are my thoughts on it: http://manoflabook.com/wp/?p=28
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
Oh...I actually really liked this one, but I get your point. I do like how Larsson pulls really not well publicized physiological abnormalities that I personally hadn't really thought much about in the past. I know it's a bit caricature-ish, but I still enjoyed the book a lot and thought it was really well written (save the situation at the end with Lisbeth...that is as much of a spoiler as I will give...I found it REALLY unbelievable so it made me groan).
Interesting review, perhaps one of the best I've read. That said, I still haven't placed these books on my TBR list. I know it goes against the trend, but as you should know by now, that bothers me not at all! Perhaps in some future time I will feel a need to read these...just not now.
My recent post In My Bag
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
Thanks Ruth! I appreciate the compliment! I don't know that I would recommend these books to you based on what I know about your reading tastes, but if you do read them, let me know what you think.
I definitely didn't like this book as much as the first one. I thought it didn't flow as well, and there were too many chunks where we weren't hearing from Lisbeth (who is, by far, my favorite character). And, like you, I also didn't love the end. However, I am still planning to read the third one. I also like watching the movies after reading the books! I cannot imagine the new movies being close to as good as these. I am in complete agreement with you about the movies. I adore Noomi Rapace... she is wonderful.
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
I saw that you said that while reading the book. I actually liked the flow of the book and thought that Lisbeth's behavior was much better explained in this book. I like how the people in her life were examined more closely and it gave insight into how Lisbeth ticked. I guess I didn't have a problem with that.

Yeah, the end was just very unbelievable to me, but I'm willing to overlook it because I liked the story a lot. :)
Great review. I think this was my favourite book of the series. I agree the end is a little... out there, but I've always read these with the sense of a heightened reality if you know what I mean.
My recent post Our World Book Night – the idea from Nicola Morgan
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
Haha! The end is TOTALLY out there. It was kind of like watching a bad B-movie or something, but I like the characters and the story so much that I didn't really care. Like I said, suspension of disbelief aided my enjoyment of this book!
I loved this book. I am still deciding whether his book, or the first one, was my favourite in the trilogy. I liked the end. I felt it fit well with the story and what we have come to expect from Lisbeth. Maybe it'll make more sense in the third ;) I guess it was unrealistic but sometimes we need a kickarse heronie that defies realism!
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
It is what we have come to expect from Lisbeth, but it was just so darn unbelievable! Still, I love Lisbeth. She's my favorite female literary character of all-time I think. There are a few others that I really like, but she is probably tops. I just love how perfectly flawed she is. It makes her so much more likable.
I have still not read the first book, though I have it. I think I will read it soon - everyone seems to have read the series!
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
Oh the first book is SO good. You will definitely have to let me know when you read it. I LOVED it.
I skimmed this as I may read the series one day. Glad to see that you enjoyed it though!!
My recent post Review- Cracked Up To Be by Courtney Summers
1 reply · active 733 weeks ago
I think you would like it, Amy. Someday you should read it. How is your TBR Dare going?
Sorry to revive a dead thread - I've only just found your blog, it's excellent - but I read this one quite recently, haven't seen the film. I agree with everything you've written about it - my only complaint would be the far-fetched ending detracts from all that gritty realism that the rest of the book spent building up. Makes for a pretty good twist though. Thanks for a great review, keep writing!
My recent post DC-WB developing a Hawkman movie

Post a new comment

Comments by

Related Posts with Thumbnails
 
Home | Gallery | Tutorials | Freebies | About Us | Contact Us

Copyright © 2009 A Little Bookish |Designed by Templatemo |Converted to blogger by BloggerThemes.Net

Usage Rights

DesignBlog BloggerTheme comes under a Creative Commons License.This template is free of charge to create a personal blog.You can make changes to the templates to suit your needs.But You must keep the footer links Intact.